When we set out to achieve long-term goals—whether it’s losing weight, improving fitness, or building healthier habits—it’s easy to believe that self-control and willpower are the keys to success. The idea is simple: resist temptations, stay disciplined, and you’ll reach your goal.
But while self-control can help in the short term, relying on it as your main strategy is a recipe for failure. Here’s why, and more importantly, what you should be doing instead.
The Problem with Willpower
There’s no doubt that willpower is powerful. It can help you push through a tough workout, say no to an extra portion of dessert, or get out of bed early when you’d rather sleep in. But here’s the catch—willpower is a finite resource. Every time you resist a temptation, make a difficult choice, or force yourself to take action against your impulses, you’re using up mental energy.
At first, when motivation is high, this might not seem like a problem. You start strong, making good choices and feeling in control. But over time, as life gets in the way, stress builds up, and motivation fluctuates, you become more likely to slip into old habits. This effect is amplified when:
- You’re tired or emotionally drained.
- Your environment is filled with temptations.
- Social pressure encourages you to make the easy, enjoyable choice.
- The behavior you’re trying to change feels restrictive rather than enjoyable.
Additional reading: If you struggle with balancing healthy eating during social situations, read Why Planned Cheat Meals Are Great (And Spontaneous Cheat Meals Are Dangerous!).
This explains why so many people struggle with consistency. It’s not that they lack willpower—it’s that willpower alone isn’t a sustainable strategy for long-term success.
Psychologists call this phenomenon ego depletion, which suggests that self-control draws on a limited pool of mental resources that can be used up over time. Studies have shown that when people exert self-control in one area (like resisting junk food), they often struggle to exert it elsewhere (like staying patient in a frustrating situation). This means the more you rely on willpower, the more likely you are to fail when you need it most.
A Better Approach: Planning Ahead
Instead of relying on willpower, a more effective strategy is to plan ahead and create an environment that makes success easier. This engages the logical, long-term-focused part of your brain before you find yourself in a situation where temptation is high.
1. Identify Risky Situations
Think about the moments where you’re most likely to stray from your plan. Is it when you’re tired after work? When you’re out with friends? When there’s easy access to unhealthy food? Awareness is the first step in preventing setbacks.
2. Create “If-Then” Plans
“If-then” planning, also known as implementation intentions, is a powerful way to override impulsive decisions. Instead of making choices in the moment, you decide in advance how you’ll respond to challenges.
For example:
- If I’m invited to get takeaway with friends, then I’ll check the menu beforehand and choose a healthier option.
- If I feel too tired to work out after work, then I’ll do a 10-minute session at home instead.
This simple technique removes the need for willpower in the moment because the decision has already been made.
3. Adjust Your Environment for Success
Your surroundings play a massive role in your choices. Make healthy behaviors easier and unhealthy behaviors harder by modifying your environment:
- Keep unhealthy snacks out of sight (or out of the house entirely).
- Prepare healthy meals in advance to remove decision fatigue.
- Place workout clothes where you’ll see them as a reminder.
4. Build Enjoyable Habits
If a behavior feels like punishment, you’re unlikely to stick with it. Instead of forcing yourself to do things you hate, find ways to make your new habits more enjoyable. If you don’t like running, try a dance class or hiking instead. If eating healthy feels boring, experiment with new recipes.
Sustainable success comes from designing and then building a lifestyle you actually enjoy!
Conclusion: Set Yourself Up for Success
If you’ve been relying on self-control to reach your goals, it’s time to rethink your approach. While willpower has its place, it’s not a reliable long-term strategy. Instead, focus on:
- Planning ahead for challenging situations.
- Creating an environment that supports your success.
- Making healthy habits enjoyable and sustainable.
By shifting from willpower to strategic planning, you’ll make progress without constantly feeling like you’re battling against yourself. Remember, success isn’t about being the most disciplined—it’s about setting yourself up to win.
Additional reading: Are you still finding you’re struggling to stick to your weight loss and fitness goals? Check out this article for other tips on how to stay true! How to Stick to Your Long-Term Weight Loss Goals: Understanding Why You’re Not Following Through
Need Support?
If you need personalized guidance from a personal trainer with over 20 years of experience in long-term change, sign up with Simon at Body Development Centre today. Whether online or at the Leicester-based studio, we’ll create a plan that works for you!
And if this article was helpful, please share it with others who might benefit. You can also find more tips like this on my Instagram and Facebook, for even more advice to help you stay on track.